⏰ Spring Scheduler Calling Multiple Times? Here's What Went Wrong!

 Hey devs 👋,

A few years back (around 3–4 years ago), I got a chance to work on a project involving Spring Cron Scheduler — using both XML configuration and Java annotations.

The requirement was pretty standard:

✅ Trigger a job every day at a particular time
✅ Fetch data from a table maintained by another team
✅ Process that data further

Everything worked well at first — in lower environments and even after initial production deployment.

But then... something strange started happening 😬

---

🚨 The Weird Behavior

After 4-5 days in production, the scheduled method started behaving oddly:

❌ It triggered twice at the same time
❌ Then later, three times, then four...
😵 Restarting the application fixed it — but only temporarily.
After a few more days, it would go back to calling multiple times again.

It was as if my @Scheduled method had cloned itself and started a party! 🥴

---

⏳ Take 10 Seconds... Can You Guess the Root Cause?

You probably thought of:

• Duplicate entries in the cron config? ❌

• Bad server clock sync? ❌

• Parallel jobs? ❌

Nope. The real issue was deeper... and sneakier.

---

🧠 Root Cause Analysis (RCA)

After some serious debugging and log tracing, I found the actual cause:

👉 Multiple ApplicationContext initializations inside the codebase!

Here’s what was happening:

• Some report functionality / test utility code was programmatically initializing ApplicationContext like this:

ApplicationContext ctx = new ClassPathXmlApplicationContext("spring-config.xml");

• Every time that functionality was triggered, a new context was created.

• That context would load the scheduler bean again.

• Result? Your scheduled job now existed multiple times in memory!

So if the test method ran 5 times, there were 5 instances of your scheduler bean — all firing at the scheduled time. 💥

---

📘 What is ApplicationContext?

Let’s take a quick refresher.

Concept	Description
🧠 What	It's the central container in Spring that manages the lifecycle of beans
🛠️ Why	Handles bean creation, dependency injection, and configuration
⏱️ When	It should be initialized once during application startup
❌ Don’t	Manually create it inside business logic or methods

---

❌ What Went Wrong

⚠️ A helper method used in reports/tests was initializing ApplicationContext again
⚠️ This reloaded the @Scheduled beans
⚠️ Now multiple scheduler beans existed simultaneously
⚠️ Each was independently triggering at the same cron time 😨

---

✅ The Fix: Singleton ApplicationContext

To fix this, we made sure:

✅ ApplicationContext is initialized once only at app startup
✅ All scheduler beans are defined only in the main Spring context
✅ No dynamic or hidden context initialization is done in any logic layer

Here's what a proper scheduler looks like:

@Component
public class MyScheduler {
    @Scheduled(cron = "0 0 10 * * ?") // Every day at 10 AM
    public void runJob() {
        // Fetch and process data
    }
}

Let Spring manage this as a singleton, not you!

---

💡 Best Practices

🌟 Never initialize ApplicationContext manually in code
🌟 Use @SpringBootApplication to bootstrap your context
🌟 Ensure all scheduler classes are under component scan paths
🌟 Use dependency injection — not manual context fetching

---

🔚 Wrapping Up

This post hopefully saves you from chasing vague errors across layers.
The moment your @Scheduled method starts behaving like a haunted loop — think ApplicationContext. 👻

Have you dealt with weird Spring behavior like this before?
Drop your stories in the comments or reach out!

Until next time,
– Anand ☕ @ Java Bean Bag